IRTF GSEC Research Group Meeting - 19 MAR 2002

1. Pete Dinsmore presented the agenda, which was accepted

2. IGMP Security Requirement - Haixiang He
   Haixiang gave the presentation, which is posted along with these
   minutes.
   - DISCUSSION - Mark Handley and Marshall Eubanks recommended
   that no attempt be made to bring this work into the IETF
   since they felt there were simpler, configuation-oriented
   solutions that are superior to using explicit security.
   After some discussion, the question was raised whether
   this work was promising to pursue in GSEC.  A poll of
   meeting participants indicated that most feel that it
   is worthy of being pursued.  The discussion concluded
   with consensus that MSEC, MAGMA, AAA, and other IETF
   WGs should be consulted towards the end of the GSEC
   work to determine what, if anything, should be taken
   to the IETF.

3. IGMP Security Architectures - Brian Weis
   Brian's presentation is posted with this summary

4. 802.15.3 Security Architecture - Ari Singer
   Ari's presentation is posted.
   - DISCUSSION - Mark Baugher suggested that the
   threats needed to be presented to understand the
   features in the architecture.  There was some
   discussion about what the role of the IETF would
   be in this IEEE standard and Ari pointed out that
   some IETF group security technologies might
   be used.  Ari suggested further discussion of
   this point.

5. Security Issues in PIM-SM  Olivier Paridaens
   Olivier's presentation is posted

6. IGMP Security for V6 Networks - Gabriel Montenegro
   Gabriel's presentation is posted.
   - DISCUSSION - Because of IPv6 anycast, we expect
   that this work should proceed independently of the
   IPv4 IGMP security work.  Specifically, some of the
   issues raised regarding the need or importance of
   IPv4 IGMP security probably do not apply to v6.